Drivers who were mis-sold car finance have waited a long time for redress, and now some lenders want to pay them early. On the surface that sounds like good news. The Financial Conduct Authority says it would welcome settlement offers, provided customers are not given a worse deal than under its proposed central scheme. Barclays has confirmed it will begin making early offers, and others are expected to follow.
The problem is the terms attached to those offers. Accepting one takes a customer out of the scheme and stops any further input from the financial ombudsman. Lenders would be able to keep the payment even if the final settlement proved smaller, and claimants could not claim more later if the legal challenge showed they were owed more. For a driver who is worried about money now, that is a difficult trade to assess, and a firm offering the sum has every reason to frame it favourably.
The FCA deserves credit for insisting that lenders be clear about what acceptance means and for publishing a factsheet listing firms making offers. Those safeguards matter. Still, the regulator says only a minority of claimants will receive early offers, which means most people must wait for the court case in February and compensation that is unlikely to be paid until late next year. Barclays itself acknowledged that claimants had already faced "a considerable wait".
Those who take the early money should be sure they understand what they are giving up, and those who wait should not be made to feel they have chosen poorly. The better course is for the regulator to keep monitoring offers closely, and for the Upper Tribunal to resolve the challenges quickly. Drivers who have not yet complained can still complain directly to their lender for free, and they should do so.